Ah,
I needed to hit the "get datasheet" button below - duh.
But there is only a data sheet for the entry labeled DU286, and none for the CHxxxx entries returned with the initial search.
This URL just takes you back to the search page:
https://www.ngs.noaa.gov/cgi-bin/ds_desig.prl
even though that is the URL that I'm on when viewing the datasheet
Some info from the page - they even have two pictures on file, and the bottom part talks about some confusion about the markers.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
PROGRAM = datasheet95, VERSION = 8.12.5.2
1        National Geodetic Survey,   Retrieval Date = MAY 20, 2019
 DU2086 ***********************************************************************
 DU2086  DESIGNATION -  SUPERSTITION
 DU2086  PID         -  DU2086
 DU2086  STATE/COUNTY-  AZ/PINAL
 DU2086  COUNTRY     -  US
 DU2086  USGS QUAD   -  GOLDFIELD (1981)
 DU2086
 DU2086                         *CURRENT SURVEY CONTROL
 DU2086  ______________________________________________________________________
 DU2086* NAD 83(1992) POSITION- 33 24 39.66108(N) 111 24 02.75525(W)   ADJUSTED  
 DU2086* NAVD 88 ORTHO HEIGHT -  1542.1   (meters)     5059.    (feet) VERTCON   
 DU2086  ______________________________________________________________________
 DU2086  GEOID HEIGHT    -        -28.912 (meters)                     GEOID12B
 DU2086  LAPLACE CORR    -          4.13  (seconds)                    DEFLEC12B
 DU2086  HORZ ORDER      -  FIRST
 DU2086
 DU2086.The horizontal coordinates were established by classical geodetic methods
 DU2086.and adjusted by the National Geodetic Survey in August 1993.
 DU2086.
 DU2086.The NAVD 88 height was computed by applying the VERTCON shift value to
 DU2086.the NGVD 29 height (displayed under SUPERSEDED SURVEY CONTROL.)
 DU2086
 DU2086.Significant digits in the geoid height do not necessarily reflect accuracy.
 DU2086.GEOID12B height accuracy estimate available here.
 DU2086
 DU2086.Photographs are available for this station.
 DU2086
 DU2086.The Laplace correction was computed from DEFLEC12B derived deflections.
 DU2086
 DU2086. The following values were computed from the NAD 83(1992) position.
 DU2086
 DU2086;                    North         East     Units Scale Factor Converg.
 DU2086;SPC AZ C     -   267,451.058   261,343.312   MT  0.99992838   +0 17 02.7
 DU2086;SPC AZ C     -   877,464.10    857,425.56   iFT  0.99992838   +0 17 02.7
 DU2086;UTM  12      - 3,696,925.591   462,736.598   MT  0.99961712   -0 13 14.4
 DU2086
 DU2086!             -  Elev Factor  x  Scale Factor =   Combined Factor
 DU2086!SPC AZ C     -   0.99976249  x   0.99992838  =   0.99969089
 DU2086!UTM  12      -   0.99976249  x   0.99961712  =   0.99937970
 DU2086
 DU2086:                Primary Azimuth Mark                     Grid Az
 DU2086:SPC AZ C     -  SUPERSTITION AZ MK                       203 39 38.8
 DU2086:UTM  12      -  SUPERSTITION AZ MK                       204 09 55.9
 DU2086
 DU2086_U.S. NATIONAL GRID SPATIAL ADDRESS: 12SVB6273696925(NAD 83)
 DU2086
 DU2086|---------------------------------------------------------------------|
 DU2086| PID    Reference Object                     Distance      Geod. Az  |
 DU2086|                                                           dddmmss.s |
 DU2086| DU2031 FOUR PEAKS                          APPROX.30.7 KM 0124629.0 |
 DU2086| CH5529 SUPERSTITION RM NE                    1.760 METERS 04312     |
 DU2086| CH5531 SUPERSTITION RM 3                     6.053 METERS 17914     |
 DU2086| CZ1935 DESERT PEAK                         APPROX.76.8 KM 1795812.0 |
 DU2086| CG1129 COMOBABI PEAK                                      1854806.8 |
 DU2086| CH5530 SUPERSTITION AZ MK                                 2035641.5 |
 DU2086| DV2128 MARE                                APPROX.83.3 KM 2594119.2 |
 DU2086| CH5528 SUPERSTITION RM CROSS                 2.267 METERS 29025     |
 DU2086|---------------------------------------------------------------------|
 DU2086
 DU2086                          SUPERSEDED SURVEY CONTROL
 DU2086
 DU2086  NAD 83(1986)-  33 24 39.65650(N)    111 24 02.75909(W) AD(       ) 1
 DU2086  NAD 27      -  33 24 39.48000(N)    111 24 00.28500(W) AD(       ) 1
 DU2086  NGVD 29 (07/19/86) 1541.5    (m)         5057.     (f) VERT ANG       
 DU2086
 DU2086.Superseded values are not recommended for survey control.
 DU2086
 DU2086.NGS no longer adjusts projects to the NAD 27 or NGVD 29 datums.
 DU2086.See file dsdata.pdf to determine how the superseded data were derived.
 DU2086
 DU2086_MARKER: DB = BENCH MARK DISK
 DU2086_SETTING: 66 = SET IN ROCK OUTCROP
 DU2086_STAMPING: 1910 SUPERSTITION RESET 1965 U.S.C.G.S. 1946
 DU2086_MARK LOGO: USGS
 DU2086_STABILITY: A = MOST RELIABLE AND EXPECTED TO HOLD
 DU2086+STABILITY: POSITION/ELEVATION WELL
 DU2086_SATELLITE: THE SITE LOCATION WAS REPORTED AS SUITABLE FOR
 DU2086+SATELLITE: SATELLITE OBSERVATIONS - May 16, 2009
 DU2086
 DU2086  HISTORY     - Date     Condition        Report By
 DU2086  HISTORY     - 1899     MONUMENTED       USGS
 DU2086  HISTORY     - 1910     GOOD             USGS
 DU2086  HISTORY     - 1936     GOOD             CGS
 DU2086  HISTORY     - 1938     GOOD             CGS
 DU2086  HISTORY     - 1946     GOOD             CGS
 DU2086  HISTORY     - 20090516 GOOD             GEOCAC
 DU2086
 DU2086                          STATION DESCRIPTION
...
...
...
 DU2086'TO REACH STATION FROM FLORENCE JUNCTION.  GO WEST ON HIGHWAY
 DU2086'8.2 MILES TO A ROAD RIGHT THROUGH A CATTLE GUARD AT A HISTORICAL
 DU2086'MARKER, ALSO AZIMUTH MARK AS DESCRIBED ABOVE.  TURN RIGHT OFF
 DU2086'HIGHWAY AND FOLLOW ROAD 4.6 MILES TO A FORK.  TURN LEFT,
 DU2086'GO 0.7 MILE TO A ROAD LEFT.  TURN LEFT, GO 0.2 MILE TO A
 DU2086'FORK.  TAKE MAIN TRAVELED ROAD TO RIGHT AND GO 0.5 MILE TO
 DU2086'A FORK.  KEEP ON ROAD TO RIGHT AND GO 0.8 MILE TO A WIRE FENCE
 DU2086'AND END OF TRUCK TRAVEL.  FROM HERE CROSS FENCE AND PACK NORTH
 DU2086'UP THE RIDGE TO THE MAIN CANYON, EAST OF THE VERTICAL CLIFFS.
 DU2086'FOLLOW UP CANYON TO SADDLE, THENCE LEFT UP STEEP SLOPE TO
 DU2086'TOP OF RIDGE, THENCE RIGHT ALONG CREST OF RIDGE TO HIGHEST
 DU2086'POINT AND STATION AS DESCRIBED ABOVE.  A FOUR HOUR PACK.
 DU2086'
 DU2086'OBSERVATIONS MADE FROM A 1.4 METER TRIPOD.
 DU2086
 DU2086                          STATION RECOVERY (2009)
 DU2086
 DU2086'RECOVERY NOTE BY GEOCACHING 2009 (BA)
 DU2086'IT APPEARS THAT SOMETIME AFTER THE LAST RECOVERY REPORT IN 1946 THE
 DU2086'ORIGINAL ALUMINUM STATION DISK WAS DAMAGED, AND THE DISK WAS RESET
 DU2086'BY THE USGS IN 1965 WITHOUT BEING DOCUMENTED WITH THE USCGS.
 DU2086'THE THREE REFERENCE MARKS ARE STILL IN PLACE AS ORIGINALLY DESCRIBED
 DU2086' 
 DU2086'WHEN SET, AND FIELD MEASUREMENTS FROM EACH REFERENCE MARK TO
 DU2086'THE STATION WERE ALL ACCURATE TO WITHIN .01 METERS, INDICATING THAT
 DU2086'THE RESET STATION IS VERY LIKELY IN THE SAME LOCATION AS THE ORIGINAL
 DU2086' 
 DU2086'DISK.  THE RESET STATION DISK IS A STANDARD USGS BENCH MARK DISK
 DU2086'STAMPED 1910 SUPERSTITION RESET 1965 U.S.C.G.S 1946.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Thanks guys,
Tom